New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division August 6, 1985 (IAFELICE EX REL. IAFELICE v. Luchs)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-08-1985
206 N.J. Super. 103 (1985) 501 A.2d 1040 RENEE IAFELICE, AN INFANT BY HER GUARDIAN AD LITEM, ANTHONY IAFELICE, ANTHONY IAFELICE, INDIVIDUALLY AND MADONNA IAFELICE, PLAINTIFFS, v. SAUL M. LUCHS, M.D., RICHARD MANSFIELD, M.D., ILANA W. ZARAFU, M.D., NEWARK BETH ISRAEL MEDICAL CENTER, PO-I TSENG, M.D., SARVESH K. NIGAM, M.D., NICOLE COHEN-ADDAD, M.D., JOYCE CHUACHINGO, JOHN OR JANE CALABRESE, FIRST NAME FICTITIOUS, PALISADES GENERAL HOSPITAL, ISABEL LISA, R.N., DORAIKANNU BALAKUMAR, M.D., SAYED M.K. UDDIN, M.D., PALISADES ANESTHESIA GROUP, P.A., ABBOTT J. KRIEGER, M.D., EDWARD ANTONIO, M.D., ANTHONY EMANUEL, M.D., AND TELLY DE MESA, M.D., DEFENDANTS. Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division Hudson County. Decided August 6, 1985. *104 Harvey I. Marcus for plaintiffs. David P. Weeks for defendant Ilana W. Zarafu, M.D. (Shanley & Fisher, attorneys). Barbara Billig for defendants Newark Beth Israel Medical Center, Po-I Tseng, M.D., and Nicole Cohen-Addad, M.D. (Feuerstein, Sachs, Maitlin, Rosenstein & Fleming, attorneys). Peter L. Korn for defendants Abbot J. Krieger, M.D., Edward Antonio, M.D., Anthony Emanuel, M.D., and Telly deMesa, M.D. (McDonough, Murray & Korn, attorneys). OPINION YOUNG, J.S.C. In discharging the duty of informed consent, is a physician negligent in failing to inform parents of a newborn infant manifesting a life-threatening condition, namely hydrocephalus secondary to intraventricular hemorrhage, that they had the alternative of non-treatment and letting the baby die? That is the issue presented on motions for summary judgment filed on behalf of defendants, Newark Beth Israel Medical Center and *105 the physicians who treated the infant at that hospital, Drs. Ilana W. Zarafu, Po-I Tseng, Nicole Cohen-Addad, Krieger, Antonio, deMesa and Emanuel. The resolution of that issue requires an inquiry into legal duty as of the time relevant, namely November 1980, which invokes application of the reasoning and determination set forth in In re Quinlan, 70 N.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit