District of Columbia Court of Appeals March 21, 1985, 81-1615 (Rachal v. Rachal)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1985

combined-opinion

489 A.2d 476 (1985) Anthony M. RACHAL, III, Appellant, v. Ara M. RACHAL, Appellee. No. 81-1615. District of Columbia Court of Appeals. Argued May 25, 1983. Decided March 21, 1985. *477 Barry H. Gottfried, Washington, D.C., with whom John Perazich, Washington, D.C., was on brief, for appellant. Mary Lee Garfield, Washington, D.C., for appellee. Before MACK and TERRY, Associate Judges, and REILLY, Chief Judge, Retired. TERRY, Associate Judge: This is an appeal from an order granting a divorce to the wife on the ground of separation for more than one year,[1] denying the husband's claim for a limited divorce on the ground of adultery,[2] awarding custody of the parties' two children to the wife, with visitation rights to the husband, and making various dispositions of money and property. Only two issues merit discussion here: whether the court erred in dismissing, with prejudice, the husband's claim for a declaratory judgment that he was not Alan Rachal's father, and whether the award of attorney's fees to the wife was proper. I Two children were born to the parties during the marriage, Alan and Anthony. At trial the issues before the court concerned the granting of a divorce, the custody of Anthony, visitation rights, distribution of property, and the award of attorney's fees and costs. Mr. Rachal did not contest his wife's de facto custody of Alan, and Mrs. Rachal did not seek support for Alan. There was no issue as to Alan's paternity; see note 7, infra. In paragraph 3 of its final order, however, the court stated: [It is] ORDERED, that Mr. Rachal's claim for a declaratory judgment that he is not the father of the minor child Alan Michael Rachal, having been litigated by the parties (for which Alan was not made a party) fails for lack of proof and must *478 be, and hereby is, DISMISSED with prejudice. Since the question of Alan's paternity was not litigated in this proceeding, the court should not have dismissed Mr. Rachal's claim with prejudice.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.