Michigan Supreme Court June 25, 1985, Docket Nos. 69219, 69819. (Calendar Nos. 13, 14) (People v. Rehkopf)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-06-1985
Levin, J.
The principal issue presented by these consolidated appeals concerns the elements of the
*203
statutory offense of inciting, inducing, or exhorting another person to commit murder.
I
Section 157b of the Penal Code provides that a person who "incites, induces or exhorts” another person to commit certain enumerated offenses, including murder, "shall be punished in the same manner as if he had committed the offense, incited, induced or exhorted.”
1
In each of the instant consolidated cases, the defendant was charged with violating § 157b under circumstances where the contemplated murder was not committed or attempted and thus the contemplated victim was not injured.
A
Vicki Rehkopf was charged with inciting, inducing, or exhorting an undercover police officer to murder her husband, Robert Rehkopf. Before trial, Rehkopf moved to quash, arguing that since an undercover police officer would not commit murder, a necessary element of the offense — that the intended result be likely to occur — was absent. The circuit judge denied the motion and the Court of Appeals denied leave to appeal.
B
John Frederick Snyder was charged with conspiracy
2
to commit murder and with inciting, inducing, or exhorting another person to murder his
*204
brother, Arnold Snyder. The conspiracy count was dismissed following the preliminary examination. A jury found Snyder guilty of violating § 157b.
Before sentencing, Snyder moved that the sentence imposed be consistent with his assertion that § 157b of the Penal Code does not require a mandatory life sentence on conviction of inciting, inducing, or exhorting another person to commit murder, or, if it does, that such a mandatory life sentence would constitute cruel or unusual punishment and a denial of equal protection. The circuit judge granted the motion and sentenced Snyder to fifteen to thirty years in prison.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit