South Dakota Supreme Court May 22, 1985, 14366, 14441 and 14443 (Corn Exchange Bank v. Tri-State Livestock Auction Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1985

KONENKAMP, Circuit Judge.

This appeal arises from a civil action brought by appellee, Corn Exchange Bank (Bank), to recover the amount of three checks drawn on the account of appellant, TriState Livestock Auction Co., Inc. (TriState). Bank claimed that it was a holder in due course of the checks. After a four day trial, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Bank.

The checks in question, drawn on the Northwestern State Bank of Orange City, Iowa (Northwestern) and totaling $1.2 million, were payable to Elkton Livestock, Inc. (Elkton) as payment for the purchase of cattle by TriState. TriState had entered into an arrangement with Elkton in which TriState would pay advances to Elkton for cattle to be delivered to TriState for sale at auction. To facilitate this endeavor, TriState’s owner gave Elkton’s purchasing agent and his wife a checkbook with authority to write these advances on Tri

*598

State’s account and deposit them to Elkton’s account at Bank to cover its purchases of livestock to be delivered to TriState by auction day. After each auction, TriState would pay Elkton the remainder of the agreed upon sale price which fluctuated depending upon the price the livestock brought.

Over a short period of time 17 checks were written without incident, totaling five million dollars. The arrangement worked well until Tri-State’s bankers began to put pressure on the owner, Mr. Den Herder, to discontinue the practice of paying advances — which it borrowed — on livestock not yet delivered to Tri-State. The deal finally collapsed when Elkton arranged for the purchase and delivery of more cattle than TriState anticipated that it could sell.

Fearing that the advance checks being written by Elkton’s purchasing agent on Tri-State’s account were far in excess of what the agent needed to buy the usual amount of cattle, Den Herder notified his bank, Northwestern, that the three checks in question were not to be honored.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.