Supreme Court of Iowa January 16, 1985, 83-1353 (Poyzer v. McGraw)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-01-1985
HARRIS, Justice.
This was a personal injury suit by an employee of a farm partnership. The worker was seriously injured by a gas explosion and fire in a house furnished to him as a part of his employment. The partners defended in part on the ground that plaintiff’s exclusive remedy was workers’ compensation.
See
Iowa Code section 85.20 (1983). The case was however submitted on the theory that the employing partnership was a separate entity and that the individual partners could be sued as third parties. After the jury allowed a substantial recovery, we filed our opinion in
Carlson v. Carlson,
346 N.W.2d 525 (Iowa 1984). In
Carlson,
we adopted the view expounded by defendant:
... Iowa Code section 85.20 precludes an injured employee ... from suing a partner in an independent tort action for his injuries received during the course of his employment for the partnership.
Id.
at 527.
In view of our holding in
Carlson
the question becomes whether the special verdicts reached by the jury were sufficient to
*750
preserve an award against a non-partner. For reasons we shall explain our answer is no. We reverse the judgment of the trial court and remand in part for a new trial.
Defendants Dale and Dorothy McGraw are husband and wife. Defendant Verle McGraw is their son. Dale and Verle are partners in a hog raising and farming operation. Dorothy is not a partner but does own a farm which was rented by the partnership and on which the partnership operation was in part conducted. A tenant house was situated on Dorothy’s farm and was made available as a dwelling for partnership employees. It was highly disputed at trial whether or not Dorothy retained or exercised any dominion over the house.
After plaintiff was hired as a partnership employee he was assigned the house owned by Dorothy as a dwelling for him and his family. It had been vacated about a month before by a previous employee. On the evening of November 24, 1979, plaintiff moved into the home.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit