California Court of Appeal October 22, 1985, B009951 (Southern Insurance v. Domino of California, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-10-1985
Opinion
EAGLESON, J.
Plaintiff, Southern Insurance Company (Southern), issued a manuscript “all risk” insurance policy to Domino et al.
1
for a three-year period with coverage commencing on September 3, 1977, and continuing until September 3, 1980. The policy listed a number of exclusions of coverage. The relevant exclusions read:
“6. Perils Excluded: This Policy Does Not Insure Against any Loss Caused by or Resulting From:
“(E) Mere Disappearance of Property or Loss or Shortage of Property Disclosed on Taking Inventory:
*623
“(I) Any Fraudulent, Dishonest or Criminal Act Done by or at the Instigation of any Insured, Partner or Joint Adventurer in or of any Insured, an Officer, Director or Trustee of any Insured; Pilferage, Appropriation or Concealment of any Property Covered Due to any Fraudulent, Dishonest or Criminal Act of any Employee While Working or Otherwise, or Agent of any Insured, or any Person to Whom the Property Covered May Be Entrusted, Other Than any Carrier or Other Bailee for Hire.”
Domino received a shipment of 4,800 units of a particular style sweater at its warehouse on July 3, 1978. This shipment consisted of 200 cartons and had a value of $86,400. Approximately two weeks after the delivery, Domino’s clerk discovered that the record documentation for this particular shipment was incomplete. She then reported the discrepancy in the records to her superiors, and a search for the missing documentation and sweaters subsequently occurred. Despite the search, the missing sweaters were never found. Domino submitted a sworn and subscribed proof of loss on October 23, 1978, asserting a loss due to theft and a claim of $81,400 (after application of a $5,000 deductible).
The claim was paid under a reservation of rights provided for in the policy. Southern then sued for declaratory relief.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit