District Court, D. Puerto Rico June 20, 1985, Civ. 84-2623CC (Santiago-Rivera v. Royal Ins. Co. of Puerto Rico)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-06-1985
OPINION AND ORDER
CEREZO, District Judge.
This is a personal injury action brought pursuant to the diversity of citizenship grant of jurisdiction. Plaintiff alleges in the complaint filed on October 19,1984 that “[o]n or about February, 1983” she fell while in a building owned by Miguel, Alicia and Edwin Francisco, the alleged heirs of Miguel Francisco, who had insurance for this type of risk with the Royal Insurance Company of Puerto Rico. It is a direct action against the Royal Insurance Company of Puerto Rico as sole defendant pursuant to Puerto Rico’s direct action statute.
P.R.Laws Ann.,
Title 26 Section 2003(1). Defendant seeks dismissal urging that the action is time barred for it was filed well after the one-year period “from the time the aggrieved person had knowledge thereof” as provided by
P.R.Laws Ann.,
Title 31 Section 5298. Plaintiff contends that a previous suit, Civil 83-2404, filed in this court against the heirs of Miguel Francisco and against an unknown insurance company
*122
tolled the statute of limitations. Defendant claims that since the earlier action was dismissed because it was filed against a non-suable entity, the statute of limitations was not tolled against the heirs of Miguel Francisco and since the action against them is time barred there can be no action against the insurance company. The action against the insurer is time barred although for different reasons. To understand why the action against Royal Insurance Company of Puerto Rico is also barred we must first review the pleadings and proceedings in Civil 83-2404.
The first lawsuit was based on exactly the same facts set forth in the complaint before us but the defendant was identified only as “Sucesión Miguel Francisco.” A brief reference was made to an “X Insurance Company” as codefendant although no mention was made of it in the caption of the case, the civil cover sheet accompanying the complaint or in any other filing prior to dismissal.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit