Court of Appeals of Iowa May 28, 1985, 84-887 (State v. Hershey)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-05-1985

*191

OXBERGER, Chief Judge.

Defendant presents one question on appeal: whether the court erred in admitting evidence resulting from the search of her purse. She says the search was improper and violated her fourth amendment rights. We disagree and affirm the conviction.

On November 9, 1982, a customer at the Pamida Store in Boone says she saw the defendant, Judy Hershey, place one of the store’s dolls in her purse, and a store employee also says she saw Hershey place a carton of cigarettes in her purse. Hershey then left the store and was stopped in the parking lot. The manager demanded Hershey open her purse and when she did, he saw the doll inside. The manager, a store employee, and Hershey returned to the manager’s office in the store where the manager asked if she had any other items. Hershey said she did not, but when the manager left, Hershey removed the carton of cigarettes and gave them to the store employee. A police officer arrived and asked Hershey if she had any other items of merchandise in her purse. The witnesses testified that, at the time, Hershey was holding the purse tightly against her side. The defendant said she did not have any other property belonging to the store in her purse and the officer then asked if she had anything that could be used as a weapon. In reply, Hershey unzipped her purse and opened it toward the officer. He looked inside and saw a car cassette player. The officer removed it, and defendant said it belonged to her and that she recently had it repaired. The manager checked the cassette player display in the store and found an empty box. The model number on the box and the player matched, but it was not possible to tell if the player had been taken from the box.

Defendant says she did not take anything from the store and that while she was in the public restroom her purse apparently became mixed up with someone else’s.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.