Appellate Court of Illinois December 4, 1985, 84-0274 (Mulhern v. Talk of the Town, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1985

JUSTICE LINDBERG

delivered the opinion of the court:

Defendant, Talk of the Town, Inc., appeals from a judgment of the circuit court of Du Page County entered on a jury verdict in favor of plaintiff, Patrick Mulhern, for injuries he sustained when his car collided with that of Barbara Sheehan (Sheehan). Prior to the accident, Sheehan had consumed alcoholic beverages as a customer of defendant. The jury returned a verdict of $96,000 against defendant, which the trial court remitted to the statutory Dramshop Act limit of $15,000. Defendant appeals the adverse judgment, and plaintiff cross-appeals the statutory remittitur. We affirm.

Plaintiffs complaint alleged that on October 24, 1981, defendant operated a dramshop and served Sheehan certain alcoholic beverages which caused her intoxication. The complaint further alleged that Sheehan operated her car and struck the car in which plaintiff was the passenger. In addition to Sheehan and defendant, plaintiff sued his brother, who was driving the car in which he was a passenger, and another dramshop operator, The Showcase Lounge. Plaintiff reached a settlement with Sheehan and plaintiff’s brother prior to trial. The Showcase Lounge is not a party to this appeal.

On January 10, 1984, defendant filed a pretrial motion in limine requesting the trial court to prohibit plaintiff from introducing or referring to a blood alcohol report or test results of Sheehan taken on October 24, 1981, at the Hinsdale Sanitarium and Hospital. The motion made no factual allegations, contained no affidavits and stated no legal grounds, although copies of certain statutes and cases were appended to the motion. Although no evidence was introduced, the trial court heard arguments from both parties regarding the motion in limine.

In denying defendant’s motion in limine, the trial court concluded that the blood test certification requirements of the Illinois Vehicle Code were not applicable to the case because Sheehan was not arrested.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.