Massachusetts Appeals Court December 24, 1985 (Commonwealth v. Mahar)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-12-1985

Greaney, C.J.

About 5:15 p.m. on November 16, 1983, a woman (victim A) was attacked and raped on Westford Street

*308

in Lowell. At about the same time the following evening, a second woman (victim B) was attacked in approximately the same location. The defendant was accused in various indictments of both assaults.

1

Following a single trial of all the indictments before a jury in the Superior Court, the defendant was convicted of rape (unaggravated) of victim A and of the assault with intent to rape and assault by means of a dangerous weapon of victim B.

2

Consecutive terms of imprisonment were imposed.

3

Represented by new counsel on appeal, the defendant argues: (1) that his motion for a required finding of not guilty should have been allowed with respect to so much of the indictment as charged him with an intent to rape victim B; (2) that there was prejudicial joinder of all the charges for a single trial; and (3) that, in final argument, his trial counsel provided him with ineffective assistance. We affirm.

We first summarize the evidence in the Commonwealth’s case as to each incident as well as the evidence presented for the defense.

The victim A incident.

Victim A testified that on November 16, 1983, she left work in Lowell at 5:00 p.m. and boarded a bus. At approximately 5:15 p.m. , she got off the bus and began walking towards her apartment on Westford Street. A man, whom she later identified as the defendant, approached her from the rear and said hello. As she returned the greeting, she had a full face view of the man, who then asked whether she was “busy the next night.” She replied that she was. The man also told her that he lived in the area. The victim continued

*309

on her way, leaving the man about six feet behind. As she approached the vicinity of 377 Westford Street, the man pulled her left arm back and covered her mouth. He then pushed the victim into a yard and to the ground, where he pulled off her pants and her underwear.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.