Supreme Court of Minnesota March 8, 1985, C6-83-1295 (Telephone Associates, Inc. v. St. Louis County Board)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-03-1985
OPINION
TODD, Justice.
Telephone Associates, Inc. submitted a bid to St. Louis County for installation of phone service. The contract was let to Norstan Communications Systems, Inc. Telephone Associates, claiming it was the lowest possible bidder, sought to enjoin the contract between Norstan and the county. The trial court denied motions for both temporary and permanent injunctions. The court of appeals reversed the trial court. We affirm the reversal of the trial court, but remand with instructions as to what relief is appropriate.
In 1982, construction of a new state office building which was to include space for certain St. Louis County offices was nearing completion in Duluth, Minnesota. At that time the county’s purchasing agent contracted with Northwestern Bell for the installation of a phone system at cost of approximately $1,000,000. After Telephone Associates appeared at a county board meeting and objected to the award of the contract without competitive bidding, the contract with Northwestern Bell was rescinded and the county accepted bids for the installation contract.
St. Louis County decided to evaluate the bids on the basis of four criteria: cost, vendor support, system quality, and optional items. Cost constituted 50% of the evaluation decision; vendor support 20%; system quality 20%; and optional items 10%. The cost element included total installation costs plus an estimate of monthly maintenance costs. Telephone Associates submitted a bid of $544,681; Norstan submitted a bid of $544,904. The county then had the bids evaluated by its engineer and purchasing agent in consultation with others experienced in the communication field. In the course of their evaluation, they discovered that Norstan had not responded directly to the bid solicitation form’s request for cost of maintenance information. That information was requested as follows:
B. Maintenance contract costs are to be included as specified in section VI, of this RPP.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit