District of Columbia Court of Appeals July 10, 1985, 84-53 (Vernell v. Gould)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-1985

ROGERS, Associate Judge:

On appeal from a dismissal of their wrongful eviction action for failure to comply with a discovery order under Super.Ct. Civ.R. 37, appellants

1

contend the trial court abused its discretion by imposing the sanction of dismissal. We agree and reverse.

I

Appellants filed a complaint for wrongful eviction and destruction of property on November 30, 1982, following their eviction from commercial properties on February 19, 1980, after appellees had obtained a judgment for possession.

2

Appellees filed an answer on December 22, 1982, and on January 6, 1983, filed their first set of interrogatories and request for documents. When appellants did not answer or otherwise acknowledge the discovery request, appellees, by letter of February 16, 1983, informed appellants that if the requests were not answered by February 23, 1983,

*308

appellees would file a motion to compel. Still receiving no response, appellees filed a “motion to compel” or, alternatively, to dismiss the complaint on February 24, 1983. On March 14 and 24, Judge McArdle ordered appellants to comply with the discovery request by April 26, 1983, or risk dismissal of their cause of action.

3

On April 26, 1983, appellants filed a motion for an extension of time, until May 27, 1983, to comply with the motion to compel; attached to the motion was an affidavit by Mrs. Vernell stating that she had been out-of-town until April 17, 1983, and thus had no knowledge of the discovery requests. The unopposed motion was granted on May 9, 1983.

On May 27, 1983, appellants submitted answers to the interrogatories and produced approximately 170 pages of documents in response to the request for production.

4

On June 23, 1983, Mrs. Vernell authorized the release of medical records to appellees’ attorneys, and she and the corporate appellants filed supplemental answers to the interrogatories and produced additional documents.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.