Supreme Judicial Court of Maine February 11, 1985 (State v. Glidden)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-02-1985
WERNICK, Active Retired Justice.
In June, 1983 the grand jury convened in Penobscot County indicted the defendant Harold Glidden charging in four Counts that in April, 1983 he had committed the crimes of Burglary and Theft,
1
respectively, in the homes in Corinna of Sue Wolfe (Counts I & III) and of Gerald S. Wark (Counts II & IV). In March, 1984 a jury found the defendant guilty as charged in Counts I, II and III and of simple theft under Count IV. The defendant’s appeal to this Court raises the single issue whether there was prejudicial error in the presiding justice’s instructions to the jury regarding the defense of duress. We deny the appeal and affirm the judgments of conviction.
The prosecution’s theory of the defendant’s guilt was that he had been an accomplice of one Joseph Albert. A connection between the defendant and Albert appeared with particular cogency in the evidence relating to Count III of the indictment, which showed that at Albert’s request, the defendant had tried to sell a unique diamond ring stolen in the April, 1983 burglary of Sue Wolfe’s home. Such evidence could establish “theft” under 17-A M.R.S.A. § 353 (1983) in that it could support a conclusion that the defendant had “exercised unauthorized control over the property of another with intent to deprive him thereof.”
In light of testimony by the defendant that Albert, who the defendant knew had no qualms about killing, had impliedly threatened the defendant with serious bodily injury, or even death, in regard to a prior incident, the presiding justice instructed the jury that as to the Count III charge of theft, it was entitled to consider whether the defendant had acted under duress imposed by Albert.
2
The justice, however, refused to instruct the jury that it could consider duress in relation to the charges of burglary at the Wolfe and Wark homes (Counts I & II) and of theft of Wark’s property (Count IV).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit