District Court, S.D. New York April 3, 1985, 83 Civ. 8554 (MJL) (St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance v. Protection Mutual Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-04-1985
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
LOWE, District Judge.
This is an action between two insurance companies which dispute liability for a building fire loss. The parties agree that there are no disputed material issues of fact and cross move for summary judgment. For the reasons stated below we deny summary judgment to plaintiff, we grant summary judgment to defendant and dismiss the action.
BACKGROUND
The dispute centers around commercial real estate on the west side of Manhattan. The premises in question were held by Paul Saurel and The United States Trust Company as trustees under a will (“Trust”). Part of the premises were leased to the Pellón Corporation (“Pellón”) pursuant to a written lease with Trust which
inter alia
provided that if the premises were damaged by fire the landlord (Trust) would bear the cost of repair. (Lease ¶ 9, annexed to affidavit of Edward Masterson as Exhibit “E”).
Trust entered into a contract of insurance with plaintiff St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company (“St. Paul”) to protect against,
inter alia,
fire damage to the building.
Pellón also entered into an insurance contract. Pellon’s contract was with defendant Protection Mutual Insurance Company (“Protection”). The Protection policy was a general business insurance policy which covered stock, inventory and other personalty as well as fire damage to the better-ments and improvements. When the building was swept by fire, Pellón suffered
*390
$446,000 in stock and equipment losses and the premises received approximately $188,-000 in damages.
Protection paid Pellón $446,000 in personal property loss. Pellón requested that Trust make repairs pursuant to the lease. Trust in turn made a damage claim against St. Paul for the loss. When St. Paul disputed liability, Trust refused to make repairs. Pellón then instituted an action on the lease to enforce Trust’s obligation to repair. Trust brought a third-party action against St. Paul for indemnification.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit