Missouri Court of Appeals August 6, 1985, WD 36306 (Stuart v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1985

NUGENT, Presiding Judge.

Defendant State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company appeals from a judgment in James Stuart’s favor. Plaintiff sued the defendant, his insurer, on the uninsured motor vehicle provisions of his insurance policies. The company complains that the evidence was insufficient to support submission of the case to the jury, that the court erred in the admission of expert testimony and in giving the damage instruction, that plaintiff’s closing argument was improper, and that the court erred in permitting juror misconduct. We affirm.

In July of 1978, Mr. Stuart, a resident of Missouri, and his family were en-route to Southern Arkansas. As he was driving through a convenience store parking lot near Hot Springs, Arkansas, a car driven by the then Rebecca Jo Taylor struck plaintiff’s car. Mr. Stuart testified that he got out of his car, went over to Ms. Taylor’s vehicle and spoke with her. Over defendant’s objection, he further testified that she told him that the accident was her fault, that the car was owned by her husband, and that she did not have insurance but that her husband worked in a body shop and would repair his car free of charge. After the accident was reported to the police, the Stuarts completed their family trip. Plaintiff claims that in the collision he incurred a neck fracture that caused him to suffer headaches and insomnia.

At the time of the accident, plaintiff had six insurance policies with the defendant each of which provided him uninsured motor vehicle coverage.

At a later time not specified in the record, plaintiff and his wife drove back to Hot Springs to find Ms. Taylor. They first inquired of the Garland County Sheriff, but his files revealed no record of the other driver. A driver’s license check was also fruitless. Without success, they called all the Taylors listed in the local telephone book and all the local body shops trying to find Ms. Taylor or her husband.

Plaintiff’s attorney also tried to find the elusive Ms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.