Supreme Court of Arkansas December 2, 1985, 85-193 (River Valley, Inc. v. American States Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-12-1985

George Rose Smith, Justice.

This second appeal in related litigation comes to this court under Rule 29(l)(j). For our first opinion, see B.G. Coney Co. v. Radford Petroleum Equipment Co., 287 Ark. 108, 696 S.W.2d 745 (1985).

B.G. Coney Company was the prime contractor for the construction of a shopping center in Little Rock. Coney failed to pay all its subcontractors and materialmen, some pf whom are the present appellants. Coney had executed a $2,090,000 contractor’s bond, on which the appellee, American States Insurance Company, was the surety. When the appellants filed their claims against the bond, the surety denied liability on the ground that the only obligees named in the bond were the developer of the shopping center and the bank which had financed it. The appellants responded by asking that the bond be reformed to conform to the terms of an earlier bond that would have covered the claims of subcontractors and materialmen. The chancellor refused the request for reformation, on the ground that it is not supported by clear and convincing evidence. The correctness of that decision is the principal issue on appeal.

The facts are almost undisputed. The first bond, signed on June 14, 1982, was a performance and payment bond. It would have covered the claims of the appellants and have complied with the pertinent statutes, including Ark. Stat. Ann. § 51-635 (Repl. 1971). The bank, however, refused to accept that bond, because the bank’s financing agreement required that it be named as an obligee in the bond, and the only obligee in the first bond was the developer of the shopping center. That bond was accordingly marked VOID.

It was replaced by a second bond in the same amount and executed by the same local agent for the corporate surety, the appellee. That agent, however, instead of using the same bond form with an added obligee, selected a different form of bond, called a dual obligation bond, which provides that it protects only the developer and the bank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.