New York Court of Appeals December 19, 1985 (SHAD Alliance v. Smith Haven Mall)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1985
combined-opinion
66 N.Y.2d 496 (1985) SHAD Alliance et al., Respondents, v. Smith Haven Mall, Appellant. Court of Appeals of the State of New York. Argued October 15, 1985. Decided December 19, 1985. Robert S. Smith and Audrey S. Feinberg for appellant. Christopher A. Hansen and Steven R. Shapiro for respondents. Edward R. Korman and Naomi Siegel for The New York Government Affairs Committee of the International Council of Shopping Centers, amicus curiae. Judges JASEN, SIMONS, KAYE and ALEXANDER concur with Judge TITONE; Judge JASEN concurs in a separate concurring opinion; Chief Judge WACHTLER dissents and votes to affirm in another opinion in which Judge MEYER concurs. *498TITONE, J. All members of the court agree that the right to free expression is one of this Nation's most cherished civil liberties. We differ solely on the question whether article I, § 8 of our State Constitution,[1] considered in light of both history and modern conditions, precludes the owner of a private shopping mall from enforcing a blanket no-handbilling policy and compels the owner to permit use of the mall for the distribution of leaflets opposing nuclear energy. As the court concludes that article I, § 8 only limits State action, not present here, the order of the Appellate Division should be reversed and a declaration made in defendant's favor. I Smith Haven Mall, a typical suburban shopping center located in central Suffolk County, Long Island, is privately owned and operated by defendant Prudential Insurance Company of America. It consists of 97 acres, of which 85 acres are dedicated to parking facilities, and contains three major department stores and approximately 125 other stores, restaurants, and service businesses, all connected by pedestrian walkways. Each of the commercial establishments is a tenant, paying rent for the use of space. The Mall has consistently and nondiscriminatorily prohibited all leafletting, and all types of political activities or gatherings.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit