Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit August 30, 1985, Appeal 85-1128 to 85-1132 (William S. Russell, William M. Hetherington, Robert E. Henry, Daniel J. Houlihan, and Ronald E. Oswill v. Department of Transportation, Faa)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-08-1985

PER CURIAM.

On the basis of the Merit Systems Protection Board’s opinion in each of these cases, we affirm the board’s decision sustaining removal of petitioners for participation in a strike and unauthorized absence. 5 U.S.C. § 7703(c) (1982).

Petitioner Russell argues that his absence from work was involuntary due to his fear of not becoming certified in retaliation for failure to join the strike. However, such an argument was rejected in

Johnson v. Department of Transportation, FAA,

735 F.2d 510 (Fed.Cir.1984).

See Martel v. Department of Transportation, FAA,

735 F.2d 504 (Fed.Cir.1984). Petitioner argues further that his absence was due to “intense fear and anxiety over the chance that he would endanger himself [and] his family ... if he defied PATCO and reported for work during the strike.” However, he told his supervisor that no specific threats were made to him personally and, as the Government points out, raised the point of being threatened with physical harm for the first time in his brief on appeal. Moreover, his psychiatrist testified that he (Russell) never mentioned fear from physical harm. Finally, petitioner argues that even if his fear was not such as to render his absence from work involuntary (i.e., did not satisfy the objective “reasonable person” test prescribed by

Johnson),

his subjective fear was sufficient to rebut the Government’s

prima facie

case of voluntary withholding of services in concert with others. However, assuming

arguendo

that petitioner was motivated by

unreasonable

fear,

1

to permit his withholding of services (simultaneously with such action by other employees) to escape sanction would as a practical matter render the objective “reasonable person” test a nullity.

Petitioner Hetherington argues that he was confused and thought his employment was terminated when he received a telegram, which stated that a strike was in progress,' participation could result in removal, and that he should report for duty.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.