Court of Appeals of Texas February 28, 1985, No. D14-84-213-CV (Travelers Insurance Co. v. Medi-Rents, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-02-1985

OPINION

COLEMAN, Chief Justice (Retired).

This is an appeal from a judgment awarding appellee, Medi-Rents, Inc., damages and attorney’s fees. The Travelers Insurance Company, appellant, appeals. We affirm.

This suit arises out of the rental of a medical device known as a transcutaneous nerve stimulator or micro-ceptor unit. There is evidence that the unit was rented by Medi-rents to Travelers on February 15, 1979, and delivered to Ms. Brinda Smith. Smith was a workers’ compensation claimant. Marie Campbell, an employee of Travelers, entered into the rental agreement on behalf of appellant. The bills for the rentals were sent to Travelers and were paid until December, 1979. The original rent invoice for the rental contained this statement:

“All equipment will automatically be re-rented on renewal date unless notified by customer of a pickup or conversion to sale.”

There was no agreement as to the method by which the “conversion to sale” could be accomplished.

There was testimony that in October of 1979 one of Travelers employees notified Medi-rents that Travelers wished to convert this rental agreement into a sale. Rental payments in excess of the purchase price had been made and the representative *501of the insurance company asked that a credit be allowed on the purchase price. No definite agreement was reached on this point and the following month, after Smith filed a lawsuit in the district court for her workers’ compensation, the insurance company stopped making payments for the rental. However, the micro-ceptor unit was not returned and Medi-rents continued billing the insurance company for the monthly rental until the rental exceeded a sum of $2,686. The purchase price of the unit was $550.

The workers’ compensation suit was settled and the insurance company agreed to “assume all responsibility” for the bills from Medi-rents, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.