Missouri Court of Appeals May 14, 1985, No. WD 36038 (Klinginsmith v. Missouri Department of Consumer Affairs)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1985

CLARK, Presiding Judge.

This is a suit for declaratory judgment seeking a determination of whether a health services corporation is obligated to include chiropractic treatments as a covered benefit for members. The trial court found the issues in favor of defendants and plaintiffs appeal. Reversed.

The facts of the case were stipulated. B.J. Kilburn was a member and beneficiary of a Blue Shield group plan issued by respondent, Missouri Medical Services. In July and August, 1981, Kil-burn sought and was furnished treatment by Charles M. Klinginsmith, a practitioner of chiropractic. A bill of $220.00 for those treatments was submitted to Missouri Medical Services but was rejected on the ground that chiropractic manipulations are not included in the Blue Shield schedule of covered benefits. This suit followed.1.

The petition in amended form as ruled by the trial court sought a declaration that health services corporations, such as Missouri Medical Services, operating under Chapter 354, RSMo.19782 are required by Missouri statute law to include chiropractic services as a covered benefit (a) when the services are rendered in treatment of an ailment otherwise covered by the health care plan, and (b) when the ailment is one which a licensed chiropractor is authorized to treat. As additional relief, the petition sought a declaration that respondent Missouri Department of Consumer Affairs, Regulation and Licensing, Division of Insurance has a duty to apply anti-discrimination statutes, § 375.934 and § 375.936, to health services corporations and to invoke sanctions for non-compliance.

An understanding of the origin of this controversy requires first an explanation of the somewhat artificial distinction made between health services corporations and insurance companies. A health service corporation is, in the case of Blue Shield, for example, an association of participating physicians.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.