Colorado Court of Appeals September 5, 1985, No. 84CA1040 (Garcia ex rel. Garcia v. Scimemi)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-09-1985

PIERCE, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Rodger W. Garcia, by and through his parents, Ignacio and Wanda Garcia, and the parents individually, appeal from a trial court order dismissing plaintiffs’ complaint against defendant Paul A. Scimemi. The dismissal followed the trial court’s order prohibiting Rodger Garcia from presenting testimony and followed the parties’ stipulation that without the testimony of Rodger Garcia, plaintiffs could not survive a motion for directed verdict of liability in defendant’s favor. The defendant then moved for dismissal of the complaint for failure of proof, which was granted, and the court’s order of dismissal was made final. We reverse.

As a result of a car accident, Rodger Garcia was hospitalized. During his hospi*1095talization, he was interviewed by Archie Belford, a specialist on multi-level communication and hypnosis, in hopes of stimulating his memory about the accident. Scime-mi filed a motion in limine to prohibit Garcia’s testimony based on its being a hypnotically induced recollection of the accident. Pursuant to this motion, the trial court heard testimony from Belford who denied hypnotizing Garcia, and heard testimony from a psychiatric expert, Dr. Roberts, who had listened to a tape recording of Bel-ford’s interview of Rodger Garcia.

Dr. Roberts initially opined that Belford had “made attempts” to put Garcia into a trance, and that Belford’s tone of voice and demeanor were similar to those used in a particular method of trying to induce a trance. However, he also testified that there was no way to tell by listening to a tape whether a person is being hypnotized, and that he had no way of knowing whether there was or was not a trance. At a later hearing, after interviewing Rodger Garcia, Dr. Roberts testified that Garcia was not an individual who was particularly susceptible to hypnosis. He then concluded that although it was “conceivable” that Garcia was hypnotized, it was “unlikely.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.