Idaho Court of Appeals July 3, 1985, No. 15031 (State v. Whitfield)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1985

SWANSTROM, Judge.

Charles Whitfield appeals from his judgment of conviction for burglary in the second degree. I.C. §§ 18-1401, -1402. The trial court allowed the state to present evidence to the jury indicating the appellant may have been involved in other crimes similar to the burglary committed here. The sole issue in Whitfield’s appeal is whether the trial court erred in refusing to exclude such evidence. We hold the trial court did not err and we affirm the judgment of conviction.

On March 5, 1982, Whitfield and Ronald Jivens were arrested for burglary at approximately 1:30 p.m. in the Gate City Steel building located in Boise. The building is a warehouse, but has not been in use for a *878number of years. Littletree Management Corporation oversees the property. Two Littletree employees were at the property the day of the burglary and heard suspicious noises. One of the employees left the premises to telephone the police. When the officers arrived one of them went with a Littletree employee to the source of the noises. The officer observed two men standing next to an electrical junction box and pounding on it. Both men were arrested and taken to the Ada County Jail.

Before trial commenced, defense counsel made motions in limine: (1) to exclude as evidence certain receipts obtained by the police from a Boise recycling business, which showed that the defendants had sold approximately two tons of scrap metal to the recycler in the three months proceeding arrest; and (2) to exclude hearsay statements made by Jivens against Whitfield. The trial court initially granted both motions. Later, the state asked the court to reconsider its ruling on the admissibility of the recycling receipts. After a hearing, the court reversed its earlier decision and allowed the recycling receipts to come in as evidence against Jivens and Whitfield.

At trial, the state introduced the recycling receipts into evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.