New York Court of Appeals June 4, 1985 (People ex rel. Maiello v. New York State Board of Parole)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-1985

OPINION OF THE COURT

Per Curiam.

After being paroled from a sentence imposed upon a conviction for robbery in the second degree, relator was arrested for attempted burglary and possession of a weapon. Prior to his release on bail, relator’s Legal Aid counsel advised him of his obligation to report the arrest to his parole officer and further advised him that Legal Aid would represent him at any parole revocation hearing. When relator reported the arrest to his parole officer, he also informed his parole officer that his counsel advised him not to give any details, but, at the parole officer’s urging, he admitted violating the conditions of his parole. The admission was introduced at relator’s final revocation hearing which resulted in a finding that he had violated the terms of his parole and his being remanded for one year or in accordance with any new sentence imposed.

Under these circumstances, any violation of relator’s right to counsel under the State Constitution would not preclude the use at a final parole revocation hearing of statements obtained by the parole officer in the absence of relator’s counsel. A violation of a constitutional right may have different consequences depending upon whether the evidence obtained in violation of that right is attempted to be used in criminal or noncriminal proceedings. Thus, in People v Ronald W. (24 NY2d 732), it was held that statements given by a probationer to his probation officer in a custodial setting without Miranda warnings could sustain the revocation of probation and imposition of sentence. However, in People v Parker (57 NY2d 815, affg 82 AD2d 661), we held that *147statements made by a Federal parolee to his parole officer under similar circumstances could not be used in a subsequent criminal prosecution (but see, Minnesota v Murphy, 465 US 420). People ex rel. Piccarillo v New York State Bd. of Parole (48 NY2d 76) is not to the contrary.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.