New York Court of Appeals July 11, 1985 (People v. Rosa)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1985

lead-opinion

OPINION OF THE COURT

Titone, J.

Defendant has been convicted of murder in the second degree, following a jury trial, in Supreme Court, New York County. On appeal, the Appellate Division, First Department, reversed the judgment of conviction, on the law, granted defendant’s motion to suppress certain statements and remanded the matter for a *382new trial. The People appeal. We conclude that suppression of the statements was not warranted and reverse the order of the Appellate Division and remit for a review of the facts (CPL 470.25 [2] [d]; 470.40 [2] [b]).

On November 7, 1974, Louis Pucci, a 20-year-old college student, warned his neighborhood grocer of an impending robbery by a youth gang. In retaliation, Pucci was shot to death by two gang members, defendant Nicholas Rosa, and Eduardo Matos. Armed with a loaded rifle, Matos had pursued Pucci into the Manhattan grocery store, followed closely by the defendant. Pucci ran to the back of the store, and after defendant told Matos, “Shoot him, shoot him”, Matos fired one shot in Pucci’s direction. Defendant then took the rifle from Matos, aimed it at Pucci and fired the second shot. Louis Pucci later died as a result of a bullet wound in his neck.

Matos surrendered to the police within hours, but the defendant avoided apprehension, until he was arrested on an unrelated charge of kidnapping in Brooklyn in January 1976. On January 26,1976, after the arraignment and preliminary hearing on the kidnapping charge, the defendant was brought to the New York County District Attorney’s office for questioning with respect to the present case. After waiving his Miranda rights, he first made an oral statement to Detective Allen Grant and then a tape-recorded statement to an Assistant District Attorney wherein he admitted being with Matos at the time of the shooting, but denied firing a shot.

A Grand Jury charged Rosa with murder in the second degree (Penal Law § 125.25).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.