New York Court of Appeals June 11, 1985 (In re Malone)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-06-1985
lead-opinion
OPINION OF THE COURT
Order affirmed, without costs, for reasons stated in the memorandum of the Appellate Division (105 AD2d 455).
Concur: Chief Judge Wachtler and Judges Simons, Kaye and Alexander. Judge Meyer dissents and votes to reverse in an opinion in which Judge Jasen concurs. Taking no part: Judge Titone.
dissent
Meyer, J.
(dissenting). My difference with the majority turns on the fact that the false testimony sanctioned by respondent was given before respondent as an investigating official. Clearly, therefore, no court or government agency or official was deceived. And although others being investigated, who were represented at the taking of Lewis’ statement through the attorney for their union, were for the time being deceived, there was a valid governmental purpose (protection of Lewis as a witness whose physical being, if not life, was believed to be in danger) and before the matter went to hearing before the arbitrator Lewis’ true statement was voluntarily revealed to the union attorney.
DR 1-102 (A) (4) provides that, “A lawyer shall not * * * Engage in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation”, and Judiciary Law § 487 makes it a misdemeanor for an attorney to be “guilty of any deceit or collusion * * * with intent to deceive the court or any party”. But Penal Law § 35.05 provides that “conduct which would otherwise constitute an offense is justifiable and not criminal when: 1. such conduct is * * * performed by a public servant in the reasonable exercise of his official powers, duties or functions”. Moreover, the Supreme Court has acknowledged that “there are circumstances when the use of deceit is the only practicable law enforcement technique available” (United States v Russell, 411 US 423, 436), as have the courts of this State (People v Archer, 68 AD2d 441, affd 49 NY2d 978, cert denied 449 US 839; Matter of Nigrone v Murtagh, 46 AD2d 343, affd 36 NY2d 421).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit