Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 31, 1985, (Claim No. 1.)(Claim No. 2.) (Troy Publishing Co. v. Dwyer)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-1985

OPINION OF THE COURT

Yesawich, Jr., J.

A felony complaint dated August 15,1984 charged respondent David M.* with murder, robbery and burglary. Following a *328preliminary hearing held six days later, the charges were dismissed for lack of probable cause. A series of articles printed in a newspaper published by petitioner reported the events surrounding the homicide, David M.’s alleged involvement therein and the related court proceedings.

On September 28, 1984, the People, in an effort to secure evidence believed to bear on the killing, moved in Rensselaer County Court for an order compelling David M. to provide samples of his blood and hair. Respondent Judge M. Andrew Dwyer, Jr. (hereinafter respondent), heard the motion, at the outset of which David M.’s counsel made an application to have the courtroom closed to the press and public. After according a reporter from petitioner’s newspaper, as well as its counsel, an opportunity to be heard in opposition to the closure application, respondent ordered the courtroom closed and declined to make a transcript of the hearing available to petitioner on the ground that David M.’s privacy interest outweighed the newspaper’s interest in disclosure; respondent also observed that petitioner would get the information it sought if and when David M. was later indicted. This proceeding ensued.

Respondent’s initial argument, that the petition fails to allege facts sufficient to justify relief under CPLR article 78, is virtually identical to that previously considered and rejected by this court when respondent’s motion to dismiss the petition herein was denied. The doctrine of law of the case precludes relitigating that issue (see, e.g., Siegel, NY Prac § 276, at 333).

Petitioner’s principal claim is that there was insufficient justification for closing the hearing and that, by virtue of Judiciary Law § 4 and the 1st Amendment of the US Constitution, such proceedings are presumptively open to the public.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.