Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 28, 1985 (Abramowitz v. New York University Dental Center)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-10-1985

OPINION OF THE COURT

Gibbons, J.

At issue on this appeal is whether, under the circumstances of this case, a release contained in a dental clinic registration form signed by the plaintiff bars him from suing to recover damages for personal injuries he allegedly incurred as a result of defendant’s malpractice. We conclude that the release was legally insufficient to exculpate defendant from its negligence, if any.

On October 8, 1980, plaintiff, a 32-year-old teacher and student at New York University, was referred by a friend to the clinic operated by defendant New York University College of Dentistry for necessary dental reconstruction. The work was to be performed by dentists taking postgraduate courses and working under the direction and supervision of their instructors at reduced cost to the patient.

*344According to the plaintiff, after some initial processing and a preliminary examination, he was ushered into an examination room, placed in the traditional reclining position in a dental examining chair and subjected to a probing examination of his teeth and gums by a Dr. Weiss. At some point during the course of this examination, a female employee of the defendant college entered the examination room and advised the plaintiff that his signature was required on an official registration form. A sheet of paper bearing the simple caption “Registration Form” was thereupon tendered to the plaintiff for his signature without any explanation or opportunity for review, and was signed by the plaintiff in the midst of the examination, while still in a reclining position, and with the customarily blinding dental examination light shining in his eyes.

Subsequently, plaintiff commenced the within action against the defendant for dental malpractice, and was met, inter alia, with the affirmative defense that the form which he had signed contained a waiver of liability releasing the defendant from any and all culpability for the effects of its own negligence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.