Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York April 1, 1985 (People v. Reyes)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-04-1985
*664The evidence adduced by the prosecution, which consisted primarily of the testimony of Transit Police Officer Frank Wakely, who was the victim of the attack by defendant and his cohorts, and his partner, Officer Eduardo Martinez, was sufficient to support defendant’s conviction of assault in the second degree. Officer Wakely testified that defendant was wearing white sneakers which he had noticed seconds earlier on one of the persons who was kicking his rib cage. This constituted strong circumstantial evidence establishing that defendant actively participated in this violent attack on the officer. The attack was apparently precipitated by Officer Wakely’s attempt to subdue another youth who had previously beaten a subway passenger. In addition, there was direct evidence that defendant was acting in concert with the other assailants to cause physical injury to Officer Wakely with the intent to prevent him from performing his lawful functions (see, Penal Law §§ 20.00,120.05 [3]). Officer Wakely testified that he saw defendant standing several feet in front of him shouting, “[l]et’s get him”, when he sat up after the attack. When he came to his partner’s aid, Officer Martinez observed that defendant was standing over Officer Wakely with a clenched fist while his codefendant was kicking the officer. Officer Martinez arrived at the scene after defendant and his cohorts had become aware of Officer Wakely’s status as a police officer, as his handcuffs, gun and radio had been revealed during the attack and one of the assailants had called out to the others, “Watch out, he’s a cop”.
The same evidence, however, was insufficient to sustain defendant’s conviction of attempted robbery in the second degree. Neither of the officers was able to observe which of the three assailants attempted to grab Officer Wakely’s gun during the course of the attack.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit