Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 20, 1985 (Carter v. Mobil Chemical Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-06-1985
Weiss, J.
Appeal from a decision of the Workers’ Compensation Board, filed April 16, 1984.
Claimant, employed as a material handler, sustained a compensable injury in May 1978 when a 90-pound roll of plastic fell on his right hand. An occupational award for tendonitis of the right wrist was made. The case was closed in November 1979 on a finding of no continued disability and no schedule loss. The case was reopened on May 14,1981, premised on medical reports indicating continuing disability and work limitations. After several hearings, a referee determined that there was no continuing disability in either claimant’s right wrist or elbow causally related to the subject accident, and that the present disability related to a preexisting congenital laxity of the wrist. The Workers’ Compensation Board reversed, finding, “based on claimant’s Dr. Goldstein’s testimony, that claimant’s right elbow is causally related to the work related incident of May 1978 * * * [and] based on Dr. Shera’s findings, that the claimant has a partial causally related disability”. The self-insured employer has appealed.
Essentially, the employer contends that the Board’s determination is not substantiated by the medical evidence in that Dr. Marvin Goldstein’s opinion lacked certainty and no opinion as to causation was given by Dr. Robert Shera, the Board’s principle medical examiner. While a review of the record confirms a sharp conflict in testimony among the various medical experts, it is well established that the Board is free to resolve conflicts in medical opinion and its determination will not be disturbed *1064when supported by substantial evidence (Matter of Currie v Town of Davenport, 37 NY2d 472; Matter of Rothstein v Consolidated Elec. Constr. Co., 84 AD2d 594, 595). That a medical opinion is not rendered in terms of absolute or reasonable medical certainty is not fatal to an award (Matter of Mitchell v Nason’s Delivery, 75 AD2d 965, 966; Matter of Cyr v Bero Constr. Corp.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit