New York Supreme Court February 13, 1985 (Maurice v. Stoddard)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-02-1985

OPINION OF THE COURT

Con. G. Cholakis, J.

Plaintiff’s intestate committed suicide on May 4, 1983 while confined in the Schoharie County Jail. This action for wrongful death and for conscious pain and suffering was commenced on June 21,1984. Defendants Stoddard, Flanigan and Hulbert now move to dismiss plaintiff’s complaint alleging that the causes of action, as to them, are time barred by CPLR 215 (1) which reads as follows:

“The following actions shall be commenced within one year:

“1. an action against a sheriff* * * upon a liability incurred by him by doing an act in his official capacity or by omission of an official duty, except the non-payment of money collected upon an execution”.

The quoted section is found in CPLR article 2, and its application is limited by CPLR 201 which states that “[a]n action * * * must be commenced within the time specified in this article unless a different time is prescribed by law” (emphasis supplied).

*273The commencement of this action for wrongful death is one for which a different time is prescribed by law. EPTL 5-4.1 specifically gives the personal representative of a decedent two years from decedent’s death to commence an action for wrongful death, therefore, that cause of action was timely commenced (Dixon v Seymour, 62 AD2d 444 [3d Dept 1978]).

The cause of action for conscious pain and suffering is one which belonged to the deceased and is not controlled by any law outside CPLR article 2. We must now proceed to determine whether CPLR 215 (1), the one-year Statute of Limitations, or CPLR 214 (5), a three-year Statute of Limitations, applies.

The cause of action for decedent’s conscious pain and suffering is grounded in negligence (plaintiff’s third cause of action). There is no doubt that, had the moving defendants not been a Sheriff and two deputy sheriffs, the three-year Statute of Limitations would apply.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.