New York Supreme Court September 3, 1985 (People v. Williams)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-09-1985
OPINION OF THE COURT
Howard E. Goldfluss, J.
The defendant moves for dismissal of the indictment on three grounds, two of which are relevant and require determination.
He alleges: (1) that the People resubmitted a charge already presented to a prior Grand Jury panel — for which the defendant was not indicted without the prior judicial permission required by CPL 190.75; (2) that the defendant was denied his *502statutory right to testify before the second Grand Jury pursuant to CPL 190.50.
The defendant was arrested on May 14, 1984 on the allegation that he had sexually assaulted his eight-year-old stepdaughter, Rose Ray. It was further alleged that he threatened his wife and his stepdaughter at knife point and held them hostage in order to prevent either of them from notifying the police.
The matter was presented to the Grand Jury on May 18, 1984. According to the papers submitted herein, it is uncontradicted that the defendant notified the court that he did not wish to testify pursuant to CPL 190.50. After presentation of the evidence, the Grand Jury voted a true bill charging the defendant with sexual abuse in the first degree, unlawful imprisonment in the first degree, endangering the welfare of a minor, resisting arrest, and menacing. There was no testimony presented before the May 1984 Grand Jury concerning a charge of attempted rape in the first degree. On February 20, 1985, an Assistant District Attorney interviewed Rose Ray, the eight-year-old complainant, in preparation for trial. In disclosing specifically what allegedly happened to her on May 12, .1984, she related more to him than she testified to in her testimony before the May 1984 Grand Jury, namely, that the defendant placed his penis on her body close to her vagina and that he stopped further acts when he heard the noise of a key on the lock of the front door. Based upon the newly revealed information, the matter was re-presented to the Grand Jury in February 1985 pursuant to CPL 200.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit