New Mexico Supreme Court August 15, 1985, No. 15749 (Joseph E. Montoya & Associates v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1985

OPINION

STOWERS, Justice.

Joseph E. Montoya & Associates (Montoya) filed suit in district court naming as defendants the State of New Mexico, the New Mexico Human Services Department (HSD), and three state officials acting in their official capacities. These officials were Joseph Goldberg (Goldberg), secretary of HSD; Denise Fort, secretary of the New Mexico Department of Finance and Administration (DFA); and Peter Pence, Director of the Management and Contracts Review Division of DFA. The complaint alleged breach of contract and sought a declaratory judgment and damages. Defendants denied the existence of a contract and moved for dismissal on the grounds that the complaint failed to state a claim upon which relief could be granted. The district court granted defendants’ motion and dismissed the action with prejudice pri- or to trial. Montoya appeals. We affirm the district court.

The pertinent facts are as follows. On December 28, 1982, Lawrence Ingram, then secretary of HSD, signed a purchase of service contract with Montoya. Montoya had already signed the contract on December 27, 1982. Lucy Delgado of the Taxation and Revenue Department also signed the contract on December 28, 1982. However, before the DFA's contract officer could sign the contract, Goldberg was appointed the new secretary of HSD. Goldberg requested DFA to withhold signing the contract pending further review by his department. After reviewing the contract, Goldberg declined to enter into the contract with Montoya. As a consequence of Goldberg’s refusal to consummate the contract, Montoya filed suit seeking a declaratory judgment finding that there was a binding contract between HSD and Montoya, and that HSD breached the contract causing Montoya to incur damages.

Montoya raises two grounds on appeal: (1) the complaint sets forth a claim under New Mexico law, and (2) the complaint sets forth a claim for which relief can be granted under traditional contract principles.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.