Court of Appeals of Arizona June 18, 1985, No. 1 CA-CR 8093 (State v. Holland)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1985

lead-opinion

OPINION

LACAGNINA, Judge.

In this case Robert Lee Holland was charged by information with one count of driving when under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drugs while license is suspended, revoked or refused and one count of driving with a blood alcohol level of .10 or more while license is suspended, revoked or refused, both class 5 felonies. Holland filed a motion to suppress the results of a breath test and also filed a motion to dismiss. Following the hearing on the motion to dismiss, the court took the matter under advisement and subsequently dismissed the case with prejudice. The state appeals this dismissal.

The facts show that on September 27, 1983, following his arrest for driving while intoxicated, police transported Holland to the Squaw Peak Police Station and issued Miranda rights to him. The police began to question Holland, and at some point during the conversation, he asked to call his attorney. He made a telephone call to his attorney’s answering service, and when the attorney returned the call, the officer answering the phone informed him that Holland was under arrest for DUI. His attorney requested a confidential phone conversation with Holland, and the officer said he could arrange it, but as the attorney/client conversation began, the attorney asked about the privacy of the arrangements, and Holland responded that the officer could hear him speaking. Holland then asked the officer to step out of earshot, but he refused to do so. Because of this, the attorney could not get any information from Holland as to his condition at that time and, therefore, was unable to advise him how to proceed, whether he should give a blood test, submit to the breathalyzer test or refuse to do anything. He was also unable to advise Holland or assist him in gathering any exculpatory evidence. The conversation ended soon after, and he eventually submitted to the breath test.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.