Ohio Supreme Court May 15, 1985, No. 84-807 (Guccione v. Hustler Magazine, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1985

Cox, J.

The issue before the court is:

Did the court of appeals err in finding that an order denying plaintiffs motion for permission to be represented by out-of-state counsel is not a final appealable order, and, specifically, that it is not an order made in a special proceeding and affecting a substantial right?

We hold that an order denying permission for out-of-state counsel (otherwise competent) to represent a litigant is a final appealable order.

R.C. 2505.02 in part defines a final order as “an order affecting a substantial right made in a special proceeding * * *.” This court in Bernbaum v. Silverstein (1980), 62 Ohio St. 2d 445, 446, fn. 2 [16 O.O.3d 461], stated in a case analogous to the instant case that a motion to disqualify counsel affects a “substantial right.” Thus an order excluding counsel (otherwise competent) is a substantial right and is appealable.

Further, this court in Russell v. Mercy Hospital (1984), 15 Ohio St. 3d 37, 39, citing Amato v. General Motors Corp. (1981), 67 Ohio St. 2d 253 [21 *90O.O.3d 158], stated that modern courts have been less than precise in defining “special proceeding.” The Russell court then quoted the holding in Amato, supra, at 258 that:

“* * * whether an order is made in a special proceeding is resolved through a balancing test. This test weighs the harm to the ‘prompt and orderly disposition of litigation,’ and the consequent waste of judicial resources, resulting from the allowance of an appeal, with the need for immediate review because appeal after final judgment is not practicable.”

According to the analysis in BancOhio Natl. Bank v. Rubicon Cadillac, Inc. (1984), 11 Ohio St. 3d 32, an order excluding counsel cannot be effectively reviewed after a final judgment if the court erroneously deprives a party of his chosen counsel. The burden on that party at the end of the case to show that he was prejudiced would in effect be an “insurmountable burden.” See Armstrong v. McAlpin (C.A. 2, 1980), 625 F. 2d 433, 441.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.