Ohio Supreme Court May 29, 1985, No. 84-288 (Becker v. BancOhio National Bank)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-05-1985
Per Curiam.
The ultimate issue before this court is whether the trial court erred in granting judgment for the defendant-appellee on the basis of the jury’s special finding of comparative negligence rather than in accordance with the general verdict in the plaintiffs-appellants’ favor. The first paragraph of the syllabus in Prendergast v. Ginsburg (1928), 119 Ohio St. 360, sets forth the following standard by which the trial court’s ruling in this case must be measured: “Judgment should not be rendered on special findings of fact as against the general verdict unless such special findings, when considered together, are inconsistent and irreconcilable with the general verdict.” (Emphasis added.)
In the instant case, the jury returned a general verdict in favor of the plaintiffs, which encompassed claims based on contract, bailment, res ipsa loquitur and negligence. The jury also answered a comparative-negligence interrogatory by stating that the plaintiffs were seventy-four percent negligent and defendant was twenty-six percent negligent. The defendant argues that this special finding of comparative negligence is a complete bar to the plaintiffs’ recovery because all the plaintiffs’ claims, including their contract claim, were based upon a negligence theory — i.e., that the defendant owed only a duty of ordinary care in protecting the contents of the plaintiffs’ safe deposit boxes.
The plaintiffs challenge the defendant’s argument with the contention that their contract claim was founded upon the defendant’s breach of a contractual duty that effectually imposed strict liability on the defendant for any loss occasioned by any “unauthorized entry” into the plaintiffs’ safe deposit boxes. The plaintiffs assert that their negligence is not a defense to the breach of such a contractual duty; and, therefore, the special finding of comparative negligence in the amount of seventy-four percent is not inconsistent or irreconcilable with the general verdict in their favor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit