Ohio Supreme Court June 26, 1985, No. 84-968 (State v. Italiano)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-1985

Reilly, J.

Defendant-appellant’s first two propositions of law raise but one issue: whether the state proved that defendant gave money to the officers with the purpose to influence them in the discharge of their duties. Defendant argues that the officers’ sole duty at the pretrial is to relate the operative facts to the prosecutor, and that it is only the prosecutor who is empowered to negotiate a reduction of the charge. As a one-time city prosecutor and an experienced defense attorney, defendant notes, he was aware that the officers had no authority to reduce the charges against his client. Moreover, he asserts, the testimony shows that he did not at any time ask either officer to fail to appear at the pretrial or to change their version of the arrest of Riffle. Finally, defendant contends the only evidence possibly supporting a finding of an intent to influence the officers in the discharge of their duties was circumstantial in nature, and was not irreconcilable with any reasonable theory of innocence. Thus, defendant concludes that the state failed to show that he paid the money with the intent necessary to constitute a bribe under R.C. 2921.02.

Defendant’s argument in support of these first two propositions of law is premised upon an overly restrictive view of the role of the police officers at a pretrial. He asserts that their only role is that of witnesses, and cites the officers’ testimony and a Cleveland Police Department manual outlining the officers’ duties as proof of this assertion. For purposes of a prosecution for bribery of a public official, however, an official duty can arise from usage as well as from a written rule or regulation. United States v. Birdsall (1914), 233 U.S. 223; Kable v. State (1973), 17 Md. App. 16, 299 A. 2d 493, certiorari denied (1973), 268 Md. 750.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.