Supreme Court of Virginia January 18, 1985, Record No. 820241 (Burruss Timber Co. v. Frith)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-1985

RUSSELL, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In this action for the recovery of a real estate broker’s commissions, the dispositive question is whether commissions are earned where a purchaser acquires all the stock of the corporate landowner, rather than taking title to its land by conveyance. We conclude that such a transaction is not a sale of land in the circumstances of the case before us and reverse a judgment for broker’s commissions.

Burruss Land and Lumber Company, Incorporated (Burruss Land), was a closely held Virginia corporation based in Lynch-burg, which operated two flooring plants and, at the time in question, owned some 120,000 acres of timber land in 300 parcels located in four southeastern states. In the middle 1970’s, Burruss Land developed a cash flow problem and decided to sell its assets, either piecemeal or as an entirety.

*703F. Earl Frith, a real estate broker, had enjoyed a continuing business relationship with Burruss Land for a number of years. He had sold land for the corporation, acquired land for it, personally purchased land from it and, at the time in question, owned land jointly with William H. Burruss, Jr., its president. The corporation habitually referred its land transactions in Southwest Virginia to Frith, and he was paid commissions on those transactions which went to settlement. In some cases, he divided the commissions with other brokers who were involved in the transactions. After mid-1975, Frith acted under written exclusive listing agreements signed by Burruss Land. On June 21, 1977, Burruss Land gave Frith a written exclusive listing agreement covering 32 parcels which contained substantially all its remaining land in Southwest Virginia. Frith made about 25 sales under this agreement and received approximately $57,000 in commissions up to March 7, 1979.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.