Court of Appeals of Oregon January 23, 1985, A8306 04012; CA A31333 (Grant v. Transit Casualty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-1985

VAN HOOMISSEN, J.

Plaintiff brought this action against Transit Casualty Company, a liability insurance carrier, to collect a judgment she had obtained against Transit’s insured, Magnolia Management, Inc., a California corporation. The trial court granted Transit’s motion for summary judgment based on its affirmative defense of non-cooperation by Magnolia. Plaintiff appeals. The question is whether there is any genuine issue of material fact regarding Transit’s affirmative defense. Viewing the record in the light most favorable to plaintiff, Edmonds v. Pollock Enterprises, 67 Or App 798, 799, 680 P2d 389, rev den 297 Or 781 (1984), we reverse and remand.

Plaintiff sued Magnolia for damages arising from an automobile accident. When she requested production of certain documents, Magnolia failed to produce them. Even after plaintiffs motion for an order compelling production was allowed, Magnolia still failed to produce the documents. On plaintiffs motion for sanctions, the trial court struck Magnolia’s pleadings and entered a default judgment in plaintiffs favor. When plaintiff was unable to collect from Magnolia, she made demand on Transit, see ORS 743.783, which refused to pay. Plaintiff then commenced this action against Transit.

The insurance contract between Transit and Magnolia contained a standard “non-cooperation” clause that voided coverage if Magnolia failed to cooperate in the defense of the action.1 Transit raised Magnolia’s non-cooperation as an affirmative defense to plaintiffs action against it. See Riggs v. New Jersey, etc. Plate Glass Co., 126 Or 404, 413, 270 P 479 (1928). After considering the evidence of Magnolia’s noncooperation, the trial court concluded that Transit was entitled to prevail on its affirmative defense as a matter of law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.