Court of Appeals of Oregon July 17, 1985, 83-03330; CA A32542 (Devereaux v. North Pacific Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-07-1985

RICHARDSON, P. J.

Claimant seeks review of an order of the Workers’ Compensation Board reversing the referee’s decision that her carpal tunnel syndrome condition is compensable and that she is entitled to penalties for the insurer’s unreasonable denial of her claim. In addition to a reversal on those issues, she seeks a modification of the Board’s order with respect to her entitlement to interim compensation and penalties for the insurer’s failure timely to pay her the full amount of that compensation.

We turn first to the issue of compensability. Claimant, age 38 at the time of the hearing, began to work for the employer in October or November, 1982. Her work involved two tasks: sorting and stacking wooden blocks after taking them off a conveyor belt and operating a saw. She sought treatment for pain in both hands and forearms from Dr. Wichser, on February 16, 1983. He initially diagnosed probable bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome and later confirmed that diagnosis. The insurer denied the claim on the ground that claimant’s condition preexisted her employment.

Claimant had first experienced problems with her left forearm in 1974 or 1975 while working for a different employer. That job involved sorting flowers on a conveyor belt. She testified that a pinched nerve under her collar bone caused pain and numbness from her elbow to her hand and caused the forearm and hand to fall asleep. The pain, which particularly bothered her at night, subsided with treatment.

In 1981, she injured her left forearm and hand in a roller skating accident, causing pain and numbness from her elbow to her fingers. The pain was different than before and apparently was worse. A physician’s assistant in Dr. Wichser’s office treated her, and the pain subsided in approximately two weeks. The assistant noted on the chart of October 6, 1981, that claimant had had a numb left wrist and pain in her left forearm for three months and that it was especially bad at night through early morning.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.