Court of Appeals of Oregon October 2, 1985, 10-84-00790; CA A32802 (State v. Berger)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-10-1985

WARDEN, J.

Defendant appeals from a judgment convicting him of burglary in the first degree (Count I), robbery in the third degree (Count II) and attempted rape in the first degree (Count III). We affirm.

Defendant waived jury trial and was tried by the court on stipulated facts. The stipulation stated that defendant broke into the apartment of a 74-year-old woman at about 2 a.m. on January 19, 1984. She knew defendant, because he had managed her apartment several years earlier. Defendant told her that he was there to take her money and to rape her. When she said that she had no money, he grabbed, choked and slapped her, causing bruises. He found and took approximately $100 and, when he could find no more, took her to the bedroom, pulled up her nightgown and lay on top of her naked body with his pants down. He told her again that he was going to rape her, but he did not have an erection and did not penetrate her. He then dressed, tied the bedroom door shut with a cord and left the apartment.

The trial court’s sentence contained a finding that “for the purpose of imposing sentence, * * * the crimes defendant has been convicted of in Counts II and III herein, merges [sic] with Count I of the Indictment * * Defendant argues that the trial court should not have “merged” the convictions for purposes of sentencing but should have “merged” the convictions themselves.

In State v. Wigget, 75 Or App 474, 707 P2d 101 (1985), we noted the differences between the standards for reviewing the validity of multiple convictions and of multiple sentences. A defendant may, under some circumstances, be separately convicted for crimes for which he could not be separately sentenced. We look primarily to the intent of the legislature in . determining the propriety of multiple convictions, but, when the legislature’s intent is unclear, the standard is whether “the completion of one offense necessarily includes commission of acts sufficient to constitute violation of another statute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.