Louisiana Court of Appeal February 12, 1985, No. CA-2944 (Fraychineaud v. R-N Concrete Service)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-1985

BARRY, Judge.

Plaintiff injured his back September 15, 1982 and his employer, R-N Concrete, paid $204 weekly compensation until April 27, 1983. His suit for total and permanent disability, penalties, and attorney’s fees was dismissed. We affirm.

Plaintiff was hurt on a Wednesday but continued working and completed the next day’s work. By Friday his back pain increased and he could not work, so his employer sent him to Dr. Serio who took x-rays and diagnosed a pulled muscle.

Plaintiff returned to work the following Monday, but could not perform his normal activities. He consulted Dr. LeNoir, orthopedic surgeon, on September 24, 1982, who found a lumbar muscle spasm and osteoarthritis at the third lumbar level and prescribed conservative treatment. By November 16, 1982 the spasms ceased, he had full range of motion, and was released to work a thirty-day trial period. Plaintiff was to return to Dr. LeNoir but never did. He returned to work on November 16, 1982, was laid off, and has not sought other employment.

Dr. LeNoir said plaintiff suffers from spinal arthritis which caused degenerative changes that predate the injury. He testified the spasms were temporary and plaintiff could return to work.

Plaintiff consulted Dr. Kewalramani, a physical medicine and rehabilitation specialist, on November 18, 1982, whose initial diagnosis was degenerative arthritis superimposed with lumbar pain syndrome. Dr. Kewalramani interpreted a CAT scan as showing a herniated disc and an EMG as showing bilateral S-l radiculectomy. The doctor admitted in testimony, however, that those findings were inconsistent with plaintiffs subjective complaints. Dr. Kewalra-mani continued treatment until April 1983 and testified plaintiff has degenerative spinal arthritis coupled with a herniated disc which prevents him from returning to work as a laborer.

Dr. Applebaum, neurosurgeon, reviewed the CAT scan and EMG (by Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.