Louisiana Court of Appeal January 10, 1985, No. CA 83 1357 (State ex rel. Department of Natural Resources, Office of Conservation v. Louisiana Pumping Service, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-01-1985
LOTTINGER, Judge.
This is an appeal by the State of Louisiana, Department of Natural Resources, Office of Conservation, (DNR) from a judgment dissolving a temporary restraining order and denying a preliminary injunction against the defendant, Louisiana Pumping Service, Inc.
*41FACTS
In May, 1983, two employees of DNR inspected the facilities of Louisiana Pumping Service, Inc. on Bayou Grand Caillou in Terrebonne Parish and reported finding un-contained nonhazardous oilfield waste on the property. On August 5, 1983, a temporary restraining order was issued on the petition of DNR enjoining defendant from conducting any further activities or operations on the property. In its petition DNR alleged that Louisiana Pumping Service, Inc. was violating La.R.S. 30:4 1(1) by operating a commercial waste disposal facility for nonhazardous oilfield waste without a permit.
Defendant filed a number of exceptions to the petition for an injunction, all of which were referred to the merits by the trial court. A hearing on the rule for a preliminary injunction was held on August 12,1983, and after DNR rested its case, the trial court granted a motion for a directed verdict in favor of the defendant on the basis that DNR failed to prove irreparable injury would occur as required by La.Code Civ.Pro. art. 3601. From this judgment DNR has appealed.
ASSIGNMENTS OF ERROR
In appealing DNR contends the trial judge erred in sustaining the various objections to testimony which basically prevented DNR from proving that the defendant did not possess the necessary permit from the state.
I
La.Code Civ.Pro. art. 3601 provides that “an injunction shall issue in cases where irreparable injury ... may otherwise result....” However, it is not necessary to prove irreparable injury when the injunction is sought on the grounds that the defendant is pursuing a course of action violative of the law. Salter v. B.W.S. Corporation, Inc., 290 So.2d 821 (La.1974); Whalen v. Brinkman, 258 So.2d 145 (La.App.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit