Louisiana Court of Appeal April 10, 1985, No. 84-284 (Romero v. Continental Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1985

STOKER, Judge.

This is an appeal in a suit for damages for personal injury allegedly caused by the negligence of deputies of the Calcasieu Parish Sheriffs Department in forcing John David Romero to jump over a wall.

On October 3, 1981, John David Romero attended a McNeese State University football game. He was seated in the student section and was drinking. He was involved in a fight and was ejected from the stadium and told not to return to the student section. A few minutes later he returned to the friends he had left in the student section. He was spotted by Deputy Jon Clau-sen who called Romero to the wall separating the stands from the field. Deputy Clausen instructed Romero to climb over the wall to the field. Romero sat on the wall, swung his legs over it, and jumped to the field. In doing so he injured his ankle.

Romero originally sued the Continental Insurance Company. Later Ideal Mutual Insurance Company, the liability insurer of the Calcasieu Parish Sheriffs Department, was substituted as defendant. Plaintiff John David Romero died in an unrelated accident after this suit was filed, and his widow, Cynthia Romero, was substituted as plaintiff.

The trial court rendered judgment in favor of Ideal Mutual Insurance Company dismissing the suit. It found that it was not unreasonable to require Romero to cross the wall. We agree with the judgment of the trial court.

Mrs. Romero contends the trial court erred in failing to hold the Sheriffs Department’s insurer liable where Mr. Romero was injured in jumping down from the wall in obedience to the lawful order of a deputy sheriff, the deputy believed Romero was intoxicated, and there were alternatives to jumping down from the wall. She specifically objected to a statement in the trial court’s reasons for judgment that “Deputy Clausen had a duty to the other spectators to quell the disturbance as quickly as possible.”

Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.