District Court of Appeal of Florida July 3, 1985, No. BA-375 (State v. Englehorn)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1985

WIGGINTON, Judge.

The State appeals the trial court’s order suppressing evidence seized from Engle-horn’s home pursuant to a search warrant. Englehorn moved to suppress the evidence on the following grounds: 1) the warrant was not served by the agency directed to serve the warrant; 2) the officer serving the warrant violated the “knock and announce” rule; and 3) there was no probable cause to justify issuance of the warrant. The court granted the motion on the third ground, finding that the affidavit was insufficient; the informants’ statements constituted “total hearsay without more”; and that the affidavit did not contain sufficient allegations of the credibility or reliability of the informants. The court made no ruling on grounds one or two. We reverse.

The affidavit was executed by a police officer, and contains the following to demonstrate probable cause for issuance of a search warrant:

On November 30,1983, Mike Shaw and John Smith went to the above described residence for the purpose of purchasing cannabis. After arriving at the residence an argument broke out between John Smith and John Englehorn, Sr. During the argument John Englehorn, Sr. threatened John Smith with a pistol. John Smith and Mike Shaw both saw a substance which they believed to be cannabis and which was reperesented [sic] to be cannabis by John Englehorn, Sr. while they were in the above descirbed [sic] residence. [Your affiant] obtained this information from Mike Shaw and John Smith shortly after the incident occurred at the above described residence. [Your affiant] has possession of a sworn statement from Mike Shaw attesting to the above facts. In addition, [your affiant] has possession of an unsworn statement from John Smith attesting to the above facts.

Shortly after the above incident occurred, John Smith went back to the above described residence and discharged a firearm at or near the above described residence. [Your affiant] has placed John Smith in custody for this act.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.