Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama June 11, 1985, 3 Div. 153 (Turner v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1985

TAYLOR, Judge.

Wilma Jean Turner was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment for the sale of drugs, and her sentence was suspended. The facts in the case indicate that a Montgomery Police Department narcotics officer, Glenn Caffey, went with an informant to 530 Smythe Curve in Montgomery, to purchase drugs. He knocked on the door and Mrs. Turner stuck her head out of an upstairs bedroom window. She inquired what he wanted, and he told her he wanted “to cop some weed.” She allowed Officer Caf-fey to enter the apartment, and the sale and the quantity of the drugs were discussed. Thereafter, Mrs. Turner went upstairs and came back with a brown envelope and gave it to Caffey in exchange for $10. Caffey estimated that this visit lasted from 3 to 5 minutes.

Caffey went back to Smythe Curve four other times. On each occasion he saw and talked with and dealt with Mrs. Turner. His second visit was abbreviated because Mrs. Turner told him she did not have any “weed.” However, on the other occasions, he testified, he had at least 3 to 8 minutes to observe Mrs. Turner.

This case is appealed on grounds of an impermissibly suggestive out-of-court identification, giving rise to a substantial likelihood of irreparable misidentification, thereby tainting the in-court identification. The facts, however, seem to indicate that there existed a misunderstanding between counsel, which resulted in a one-on-one show up. The parties had agreed to a standard lineup to give Caffey an opportunity to see if he could pick Mrs. Turner out of a line-up. *666Then the line-up was cancelled. Neither Officer Caffey nor the defense attorney knew the line-up had been cancelled. At the police station, defense counsel agreed with the police that a one-on-one show up be conducted. The officer was not to be informed of the reason for his trip to the station, and they would find out whether he would be able to correctly identify Mrs. Turner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.