District Court of Appeal of Florida October 8, 1985, No. 84-822 (Gant v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1985

NESBITT, Judge.

Gant appeals his convictions and sentences on charges of trafficking in cocaine and possession of cocaine. We reverse.

A confidential informant arranged a drug purchase at Mr. Gant’s home. The informant arrived at Gant’s home accompanied by an undercover police officer who was equipped with a sound transmitter. Gant and three other men were at the house when the transaction took place. All four were arrested after one of the other men retrieved a kilo of cocaine from a vehicle parked outside.

In response to Gant’s discovery demand, the state indicated the existence of a tape recording of the transaction. A codefend-ant’s counsel went to the state attorney’s office to hear the tape and make a copy. When the prosecutor and defense attorney attempted to play the tape, it was unintelligible. Both agreed that the tape could not be used at trial.

As it turned out, the tape had been played at the wrong speed and was, in fact, intelligible. The prosecutor did not make this discovery until right before opening arguments were to begin. He then informed the court and defense counsel that he intended to use the tape. A codefend-ant’s attorney objected and requested a Richardson hearing,1 which was denied. Gant’s counsel unsuccessfully made the same objection and request when the tape was later admitted into evidence. We agree with Gant’s contention that the failure to conduct a Richardson hearing was reversible error.

Under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.220(a)(1), the prosecutor was obligated to disclose the existence of the tape recording at issue and make it available to the defendant upon request. The prosecutor attempted to comply with that request, but, by inadvertently playing the tape at the wrong speed, failed to do so, and, based upon the mistaken conclusion that the tape was unintelligible, agreed that it would not be used at trial. We reject the state’s contention that no violation occurred.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.