Louisiana Court of Appeal December 11, 1985, No. CA 3295 (Brady v. United Services Automobile Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-1985

SCHOTT, Judge.

This is an appeal by plaintiffs from a judgment based on a unanimous jury verdict dismissing their suit for damages arising out of an alleged automobile accident. The issue is whether, upon a review of the record in accordance with Arceneaux v. Domingue, 365 So.2d 1330 (La.1978), we may determine that the jury’s finding is not clearly wrong.

Plaintiffs’ principal argument is that defendant’s testimony was so incredible that there must have been an accident and it must have occurred the way the two plaintiffs described it. However, the jury unanimously decided that there was no accident thereby categorically rejecting the testimony of the plaintiffs.

On the morning of April 7, 1981 plaintiff, Goodwin, had exited 1-10 West at Carroll-ton Avenue in his company’s vehicle with his co-worker, plaintiff, Brady, as his passenger. Goodwin testified he stopped at a stop sign at Carrollton and started into Carrollton when he was struck from the rear by a car driven by defendant, David Terribile; he backed out of Carrollton two or three feet, got out to inspect the car and found a dent on one of his car’s bumper guards; when he discovered that Brady was hurt he decided to call the police. Brady testified that just after they stopped for the stop sign he leaned down to the floor of the car to get a document when he felt a jolt from behind. Brady was taken to the hospital in an ambulance while Goodwin remained on the scene to wait for the police. Following the investigation Goodwin drove to the hospital for treatment.

According to Terribile he too had exited from I — 10, came to a stop at Carrollton, and started into Carrollton when he observed Goodwin’s car moving slowly in the center lane of Carrollton; as he was passing the car Goodwin asked Terribile to stop as there seemed to be a problem, whereupon both drivers backed out of Carrollton and onto the exit; at this point Goodwin accused him of rear ending him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.