District Court of Appeal of Florida September 18, 1985, No. BE-467 (Oliver B. Cannon & Sons, Inc. v. Crosby)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-09-1985

JOANOS, Judge.

In this appeal of a workers’ compensation order awarding a lump sum payment to the claimant, the employer and carrier contend the record lacks competent substantial evidence that the award is in the claimant’s best interests. We agree and reverse the order.

In seeking lump sum payment, the claimant, who planned to relocate to Alabama, submitted expert testimony as to an invest-mént plan that would allow him to meet monthly expenses. The expert, Mr. Scano-lon, said that claimant needed approximately $2,000.00 per month to meet his needs. His current resources included $865.00 per month in total family Social Security benefits and $146.00 per month from a union disability plan, therefore he needed another approximately $1,000.00 per month. Mr. Scanolon devised a plan that required a lump sum payment of $181,979.71. Of that amount, $42,000.00 was needed for the purchase of a new home and relocation and $20,000.00 was needed to pay off outstanding debts. Of the remaining $120,000.00, $50,000.00 would be invested in stocks which Scanolon calculated would yield an average of $302.00 a month. The remaining $70,000.00 would be placed in interest bearing securities which would yield about $687.00 a month. Scanolon recognized that this income would be taxable. He also said that as he understood it, there would be no impact on claimant’s Social Security benefits. He advised that claimant should not change investments without professional advice. He had selected the particular investments for diversification, long-term growth, and as a hedge against inflation. He thought the plan would restore to the claimant a sense of financial security, and that monitoring the investments would keep the claimant mentally active. Scano-lon said that for the plan to work, the funds would have to remain invested.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.