Supreme Court of Arkansas November 12, 1985, 85-231 (Sullivan v. Employers Equitable Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-11-1985
Darrell Hickman, Justice.
Gordon L. Sullivan was at one time president of Employers Equitable Life Insurance Company. He sued the company on a contract for monthly 5% overwrite commissions due him for developing a marketing program to increase company sales. It was alleged that the contract was orally agreed to by Lester Banfield, the majority stockholder and chairman of the board of directors, and executed at Sullivan’s direction by two company officers, Vice-President Dewey Sims, and Secretary Marsha Stewart. The jury returned a verdict for Sullivan for $ 125,000. The trial court set the verdict aside on the company’s motion, finding that the contract was in no way authorized by the board of directors.
On appeal Sullivan argues that both an oral and written contract for the 5% overwrite existed, and that the written contract was authorized by the board of directors. We affirm the trial court, finding that his reasoning is justified by the record.
The case was submitted to the jury specifically on the question of whether the written contract was properly executed. There was no submitted issue of whether there was an oral contract. The pertinent paragraph of the jury instruction reads:
If you find that Marsha Stewart and Dewey Sims did not have the authority to execute the overwrite contract you are instructed that the contract is not enforceable against Employer’s Equitable and there is no contract between Employer’s Equitable and Gordon Sullivan.
The trial court stated in its findings of fact:
The contract was executed on behalf of the company by two of its officers at the direction of the plaintiff. Neither of those two officers contended that they had any authority to so do, beyond direction of the plaintiff who was president of the company. None of the three officers involved had any apparent or expressed authority to execute the contract or agree to the terms found in the undertakings of the ‘formal agreement’ upon which this suit was brought.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit