Supreme Court of Connecticut August 6, 1985, 11995 (Lake Williams Beach Ass'n v. Gilman Bros.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1985

Peters, C. J.

The dispositive issue in this appeal is whether lowering the level of an artificial lake to compensate for the inadequate design of a dam constitutes a reasonable use of water rights. The plaintiffs, owners of real property fronting on the shore of Lake *135Williams in Lebanon, brought suit to enjoin the defendants, a dam owner and its lessee, from unreasonably drawing down the lake. The trial court held for the defendants and the plaintiffs appealed. We find no error.

The facts underlying this appeal are largely undisputed. The dam that created Lake Williams was erected in the mid-nineteenth century to supply water power for downstream industrial use. The dam consists of a 280 foot-long earthen embankment, into which is set a 39 foot-long stone masonry spillway. The distance between the top of the spillway and the top of the dam (the freeboard) is 1.8 feet. The level of the water in Lake Williams is controlled by opening and closing a 30 inch diameter steel pipe that runs through the spillway wall. The mechanism that operates this “gate” is located in a gatehouse atop the spillway. The named defendant, the Gilman Brothers Company (the defendant), is the successor in title to the dam site, the dam, and the right to impound and flow the waters of Lake Williams.1 Gilman Brothers uses this water at its downstream plastics factory for cooling and fire protection. When surplus water is available, the defendant Bozrah Light & Power Company uses it to generate electricity pursuant to a lease agreement with the defendant Gilman Brothers.

Lake Williams is very shallow. It has a surface area of approximately 272 acres when full, yet it has a maximum depth of ten feet and an average depth of four and one-half feet. The lake was completely surrounded by undeveloped woodland until 1950, when construction of houses on lots adjacent to the lake began. The individual plaintiffs are owners of lakefront properties in this residential development.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.